Sunday, November 6, 2016

Keeping it clean

I have been amazed by the statistics as to what people are researching on the internet when it comes to saxophones.  This blog site has an automatic statistic compiler that shows which blog gets the most attention and the search terms that were used to reach the site.  Aside from my diversions into non-sax topics, this blog is basically about getting the best out of your saxophone.  Repair, if you will, but some care and feeding of a saxophone.  So what gets the most attention?  Which blog is viewed the most?  What is the most common concern of saxophone players?  Turns out that it is my blog about removing lacquer.  Most people are searching for how to make their lacquer look good.  It's like writing a big blog about automobile maintenance and the most hits at the site are from people who want to make their car shiny.

Lacquer, i.e., the most frivolous aspect of saxophone ownership, gets the most attention.  Will you play better if your lacquer is better?  I doubt it.  But this blog is going to be about your inner-self.  Actually, your horn's inner-self.  I've torn apart and rebuilt enough saxophones that I know that it's what's inside that counts.  And I really mean what counts.  What is inside your horn, stuff that you don't know about, will really, really effect the way your horn plays.  People talk about whether a re-lacquer effects the way a horn plays.  It is a complex issue with lots of hyperbole and folk lore.  But what's inside your horn will absolutely effect the way the horn plays, yet nobody talks about that.

Every new player gets the admonition about swabbing out their horn when they are done practicing.  Good advice, often ignored.  So what bad stuff happens to the horn that isn't swabbed regularly?  The same thing that happens to the swabbed horn, just much faster.  Even a horn that is taken care of suffers over time.  Here, I'm talking about quite a bit of time.  Since I generally work on older horns (1920's-40's), I often see stomach-turning filth, and some of it is on well maintained horns.  Think of it like brushing your teeth.  It's a great idea, but when you're 100 years old you probably will have some issues even if you brush just like your dentist says.  Same with swabbing.  You will also need a periodic deep cleaning.

One of my recent repads was a 1951 Conn 10M.  Compared to most horns that I've worked on, that's a new horn.  I always look inside when I take them apart and this one was normal.  There was stuff.  Stuff that wouldn't come out with a swab.  I have a stainless steel wire bottle brush that has adjustable bristles.  I can make it narrow or as wide as a wine bottle.  Perfect for cleaning the inside of the body tube after all the key mechanisms are removed.  Here is  a view down the bell.

See that little pile of stuff in the bow?  You can click on the picture to enlarge.  That's what came loose from the body tube with a little brushing.  Here's a different angle of what was in the bow.  This picture isn't the bottom of the bow, where stuff really accumulates, this is just what the sides of the body tube looked like.

This stuff was also in the neck.  It is formed by condensation attracting dust and stuff over the years.  How can that not effect the way the horn sounds?  Who cares of the horn is a re-lacquer on the outside if this is what's on the inside.

Here is a picture of the stuff I got out of the neck and the horn.  Notice that there is a little yellow plastic piece, probably from the octave mechanism, that came out when I brushed out the horn.  It was cemented inside of the horn with the gunk.

Because some of the stuff wouldn't come loose with just a brushing, I used my abrasive blaster and soda (a relatively mild abrasive) to blast out the stubborn stuff.  Here's a picture of what I had to blast out.  This is after I had gone through the tube with the stainless steel bristle bottle brush, so this stuff is really stuck on.
That stuff isn't in the bow, it's on the side wall of the body tube, looking in through one of the lower tone hole chimneys.  With all of the keys off, I was able to blast the entire tube.  Soda is abrasive enough to remove this scale but doesn't leave a rough or satin finish like sand.

I have never cleaned out a horn without changing anything else.  A cleaning like this requires the keys removed, and if they are removed, then the horn is repadded, the keys are swedged, the full works.  So I don't know how much of the improvement in the horn's performance is due just to removing the fuzzy crumbles from the interior.  I have to believe that a layer of scale can't be good.

Next is the pads and tone holes.  Since I always have the horn stripped down, I really don't ever clean a pad off and use it over again.  It's just not worth it.  I'll use an analogy.  I completely rebuild my car's engine. I save the old oil and oil filter because they look okay and I don't know how many miles are on them.  That saves me $25.  Really?  Ever heard of anybody doing that?

Good quality pads and resonators are about $100 on a tenor.  If the horn is taken care of, they should last over 10 years.  That's less than $10 a year to play on good pads.  Of course, if you don't work on your own horn and install the pads yourself, it costs more.  

Here is one of the issues with old pads.  This is verdigris.  
Verdigris is kind of a generic name for a green layer of corrosion that forms on metal alloys containing copper.  Citric acid, chloride, whatever, can form verdigris.  It can occur simply from salts, acids, and gases in the environment.  And moisture helps.  It tends to be a blend of copper acetate, copper carbonate and, if near the ocean, copper chloride.  Other tarnish colors are caused by other acids, but the term verdigris (vert-de-Grece or "Green of Greece) is the common term.

This is what heavy verdigris looks like on a pad.  It can be cleaned off, but don't bother.  The damage has been done.  The crystals are not just on the surface.  The moisture that helps verdigris form also carries the verdigris into the leather.  Leather used in other applications, especially structural uses of leather (think horse harnesses), have know for years the deterioration of leather caused by verdigris on brass rivets used in leather.  The tanning process leaves residual chemicals that produce verdigris.
(If you want to see how pad leather can fail while looking perfect, check out this blog.)

The affected leather can been cleaned and the verdigris on the surface removed, maybe even the verdigris formed in the moist leather, but I'm not convinced that damage hasn't been done by the crystalline structure of the verdigris.  The leather around a saxophone pad seat will be supple enough to look like the pad is sealing, but the actual seat area will have been compromised.  

Speaking of supple, go back and look at the pad shown in the third picture.  See the "water spots" on it?  Sometimes that is just a stain and sometimes that discoloration indicates a hard spot on the leather.  Check those spots carefully and decide whether you want to save a pad like that.  

You will also need to look closely at any tone hole chimney that has a layer of verdigris.  The amount of copper that makes the green patina may be minuscule, but it may also be enough to effect the sealing ability of the tone hole.  I use a flat diamond lap file, often used for sharpening carving knives, to gently put a shine on the tone hole.  That way I can use a magnifying glass to see if the tone hole is level.  

Right in the center of the picture is an area that isn't completely shiny after being lightly lapped.  The combination of leather, copper, spit, and who knows what else had, over the years, caused some metal loss.  It doesn't take much of a pad seat to hide this size leak.  The tone hole needs to be filed down a tiny amount and all is good.  Except for one problem.  I still have brass directly against leather.  And I will have moisture.  By taking good care of my horn I can minimize the amount of time moisture is present, but I can't eliminate it.

What I have done in the past is to cut to the chase and corrode the newly exposed brass so that it won't further corrode.  It's similar to the anodized finish that is put on aluminum to prevent further corrosion.  I need to corrode the copper with something so that no raw copper is exposed to acetic acid, etc. (the common causes of verdigris).  What I have used is a mixture of selenic acid and phosphoric acid.  It is the same stuff that I used on another blog to produce a brownish patina on the whole horn.  Although that horn is un-lacquered brass, there has been absolutely no verdigris formed on the patina surface in 6 years.  Not on the inside, not on the tone hole chimneys.

Shortly after putting the patina on that horn, I leveled some tone holes and was concerned about the leather/raw brass issue.  Leveling the tone holes produces a sharp edge.  I run bronze wool around them to round them over a little bit and get rid of any sharp burrs.  Not a rolled tone hole exactly, just an edge that is friendlier to the leather.

I then run my acid wash over the newly exposed brass.  I've already done it here, and it's basically invisible.  It doesn't effect the lacquer and simply takes the sheen off of the brass.  It corrodes the brass to a soft brown color and, so far, does not subsequently generate any green crud.

Now I have a surface that is clean, flat, and resistant to verdigris.  With the keys off, I can clean and inspect the inside.  Time to repad.  AND THEN KEEP THE HORN CLEAN.


  1. Would you post a picture of (or maybe a link for) this adjustable bottle brush??

    Also, how do you go about soda blasting the bore? is it through the open tone holes or some kind of angled nozzle?

    Do you load a conventional sand blaster with baking soda (is that all there is to it?)

    Thanks for the great posts.

  2. Both the wire brush and the soda blasting have to be done when the horn is completely stripped down. The wire brush will tear up the pads if it were to be used with the pads still on. The nozzle of my blasting gun would not fit and I wouldn't be able to get good coverage with the pads on. It is still difficult even with the pads on.

    I tried to Google to find the wire brush that I have and couldn't find one on the internet. I bought it years ago at a wine making shop. The little blasting gun that I use is like this one.
    The media is basically baking soda, but a box of baking soda might not be enough to do a tenor. For a few dollars more, I can get a 50# bag at my local Kleen Blast. A bag has lasted me for years and I use it on other projects. It's messy and you need to wear a particle mask.

  3. This comment has been removed by the author.